The Report, January 6, 2003, p. 25
A political retreat
Denied more cash, how can
Ottawa fund its controversial firearms-licensing program?
By PETER STOCK
Justice Department bureaucrats
could not have picked a much worse time than December 5 to go to Parliament, hat in hand,
to request more money for their gun registry. Just two days earlier, Auditor General
Sheila Fraser had revealed gross financial mismanagement of the program, including
"astronomical" cost overruns in the billion-dollar range. Now the
department wanted another $72 million to tide the registry over for a few more months.
Even Liberal MPs, virtually all of whom had voted for the registry in 1995,
chafed at the notion of throwing more money down the registry sinkhole. In a
last-minute maneuver, Liberal House Leader Don Boudria nulled the suplementary spending
estimate from consideration by the House of Commons. Canadian Alliance MP and
Opposition Finance critic Charlie Penson thinks pulling the funding request was an effort
at "damage control. They were afraid they might lose the vote. The gun
registry is just the latest item in a long list of mismanagement. The Liberals would
like to have you believe they are good managers."
Pulling funding for a program is unprecedented under the Chretien regime, Mr.
Penson comments. "We've long tried to get them to cut back the spending
estimates by even a dollar, and they will not budge an inch." Even so, despite
the clear loss of parliamentary confidence in the registry, he believes the Liberals will
"try to fund the gun registry some other way. We'll be watching to see how
they'll find the money."
Some evidence in the federal auditor general's report indicates how the
government may continue to secretly fund the program. Ms. Fraser says the Treasury
Board the government department that oversees all spending extended a
$40-million "loan" to the registry in 1996, which was to be repaid with interest
by 2005. Instead, that debt was "forgiven" in 2000. In 1996, a
further $55 million in funds earmarked for the Correctional Service of Canada and the
National Parole Board was diverted to the registry. Ms. Fraser remarked that
"Parliament was kept in the dark" about these transactions.
Yet even with the diversion of funds from other programs, it is far from
clear [how] the registry can achieve its year-end goal of recording all the firearms in
Canada. By November 30, the Canadian Firearms Centre, which operates the gun
registry, had registered 2.1 million gun owners and 5.2 million guns. The Justice
Department claims there are 2.46 million gun owners and 7.9 million guns in Canada.
But those totals are far too low, counters Jim Hinter, president of the National Firearms
Association. "They arrived at those numbers through a public-opinion survey
where they asked Canadians about firearms possession. Forty percent of the people
they called hung up. Those were the gun owners. We estimate there are between
five and seven million gun owners."
Regardless, the government will never meet its deadline for registering all
guns, Mr. Hinter continues. "If you are trying to get forms to register, you
cannot get them. The phone lines have been jammed for months. How can
Canadians possibly register on time?" The firearms lobbyist says the issue has
gone beyond simple gun safety to one of competent fiscal management. "The
debate's wide open. Where have the dollars gone? This was a bad law,
poorly designed and now falling apart. You know our election lawn signs that say,
'Remember Bill C-68 when you vote'? That sign now has meaning for all
Index to more articles from
Copyright © 2003
United Western Communications Ltd.
All Rights Reserved.
- Shot in the foot by their gun
Auditor general confirms Liberal boondoggle has cost us at least $1B, by
Lorne Gunter, The Edmonton Journal, 2002 12 04
- The Website of LUFA (Law-abiding
Firearms Association "25,000+ Members and over 5 million unlicenced
supporters!") LUFA constructed a new tourist attraction on
Highway 16A West, near Edmonton (Stony Plain), thereby commencing its National Billboard Campaign.
Their website is full of very interesting
and well-documented facts about the federal gun registry fiasco that you are not very
likely to find reported in the Liberally-dominated and -controlled major daily papers or
on TV channels funded through the federal government and promoting federal gun registry
The White Rose
Thoughts are Free